This summer, navigating through the traffic of Marseille, a moment arose that encapsulates a pressing question of our age: do we trust our instincts or the algorithms of artificial intelligence? While I was driving, my friend urged me to turn right towards a local fish soup spot, but the navigation app Waze instructed me to continue straight. Exhausted and overwhelmed by the heat of the car, I chose to follow Waze’s direction, only to find ourselves ensnared at a construction site moments later.
This seemingly trivial incident reveals a deeper issue regarding our reliance on technology. The German philosopher Immanuel Kant once characterized the Enlightenment as “man’s emergence from his self-imposed immaturity,” where individuals sought guidance from authorities such as priests and monarchs. In the pursuit of understanding the world, humans historically relied on faith for insights into natural phenomena and social dynamics.
Kant argued that humans possess the capacity for reason, yet often lack the confidence to employ it. The American and French Revolutions signaled a shift towards reason over faith, encouraging individuals to think independently. Kant famously urged his contemporaries to “Sapere aude!” or “Have courage to use your own understanding.” However, in today’s context, one might question whether we are regressing into a state of dependency on technology.
With the emergence of AI, we risk relinquishing our ability to think critically. ChatGPT, launched just three years ago, has already seen extensive adoption, with a recent survey indicating that 82% of respondents had utilized AI in the past six months. From personal decisions to political choices, many are increasingly turning to machines for guidance. Notably, 73% of user prompts focus on non-work-related topics, suggesting a profound shift in how we engage with technology.
The implications of this dependency are profound. Writing, once a primary method for self-reflection, has become largely influenced by AI. The American author Joan Didion stated, “I write entirely to find out what I am thinking.” If we allow AI to take over this process, we risk losing our ability to introspect and articulate our thoughts. A study conducted by the Massachusetts Institute of Technology demonstrated that participants who used AI during writing tasks exhibited lower cognitive engagement and an increasing tendency to copy text directly.
Though this study has limitations, its findings resonate with Kant’s concerns about immaturity. He noted that “laziness and cowardice” often trap individuals in perpetual dependence, making it easy for others to assume the role of guardians. The convenience of AI may contribute to this dependency by offering a way to offload responsibility for decision-making.
AI’s ability to process vast amounts of data rapidly sets it apart. This efficiency draws users like myself to trust technological solutions over human advice, as seen in my choice to follow Waze instead of my friend. Yet, the challenge lies in the opacity of AI; it operates as a “black box,” providing answers without enhancing our understanding. Even its developers acknowledge the unpredictability of its reasoning, which leads to a troubling reliance on technology over personal judgment.
While AI can indeed assist in many tasks—ranging from drug discovery to streamlining mundane jobs—it should not be a substitute for human reasoning. Kant and his contemporaries championed reason not merely for improved efficiency but as a means to cultivate freedom and moral responsibility among individuals. The act of thinking and debating is not solely about knowledge; it’s a process that fosters confidence and agency.
As we embrace the advantages of AI, the central question remains: how can we leverage its capabilities without sacrificing our critical thinking skills—skills that are essential to the foundations of liberal democracy? Ultimately, allowing machines to dictate our reasoning could undermine the very essence of human agency, a concern that warrants serious reflection as we move deeper into the 21st century.
For more information on AI’s impact on society, consider resources from OpenAI, or explore studies from the Massachusetts Institute of Technology and their findings related to AI and cognition.
See also
2025 Sees New Laws Limiting Childhood Independence Amid Safety Concerns and Backlash
Unlock 100% Returns: Invest in the Hidden Energy Stock Powering AI’s Future
S&E Company Launches AI-Driven Agritech Platform B•good in Vietnam to Enhance Agricultural Resilience
Elon Musk Claims Optimus and Grok Could Revolutionize Healthcare Over Government Systems
Alibaba Prepares for Market Open Amid Key AI Chip Developments, Pricing Rules Impact
