Recent turmoil in the technology sector, spurred by fears that artificial intelligence (AI) could disrupt traditional software companies, has led to significant sell-offs and dramatic drops in stock valuations. Analysts, however, suggest that this market reaction may be an overreaction, with many software firms enhancing their offerings through AI integration rather than facing outright replacement. The price-to-earnings ratio for software stocks has fallen sharply from 51 times to 27 times, positioning it below other sectors such as automotive and semiconductors, according to data from Goldman Sachs.
HSBC’s recent report challenges the notion that AI will replace software, arguing that software providers are expanding their total addressable market by embedding AI technologies. This perspective highlights a critical shift: rather than being rendered obsolete, software is evolving to become more efficient and valuable through AI integration. Morgan Stanley echoed these sentiments, noting that many fundamentally strong companies have been unfairly punished in the market, and there are significant opportunities for recovery.
Market reactions have led to a drastic revaluation of software stocks, with the sector experiencing the most severe cuts amid the ongoing AI discourse. Morgan Stanley pointed out that while many viewed these companies as ‘disrupted by AI,’ their core business models and profitability remain intact. In fact, firms that successfully integrate AI are likely to experience margin expansions rather than declines, as they leverage AI for improved efficiency.
Analysts from various firms agree that AI’s initial impact on enterprises is more pronounced in cost efficiency rather than revenue growth. A survey conducted by Morgan Stanley indicates that between 74% and 90% of analysts expect profit margins to increase through cost savings in the next 12 to 24 months. This suggests that software companies embracing AI are not suffering losses in profitability; instead, they are poised for enhancements.
AI Enhances Rather Than Replaces
HSBC’s rebuttal to the ‘AI will replace software’ narrative emphasizes that AI is meant to augment rather than replace core software functionalities. Leading enterprise software giants like SAP and Oracle have built enduring competitive advantages through their mastery of proprietary data, domain expertise, and optimized software architectures. These entrenched positions provide them with resilience against AI-generated solutions in enterprise applications.
HSBC also noted the technological limitations of current AI applications, particularly the ‘hallucination’ problem, which impedes AI’s ability to consistently meet the stringent accuracy demands of enterprise systems. As the media amplifies the narrative of AI versus software, companies within the Global 2000 are finding opportunities for growth in their total addressable markets and enhanced cost efficiencies through AI integration.
Data from Morgan Stanley illustrates a widening gap in performance between AI adopters and those perceived as vulnerable to disruption. Since late 2023, AI adopters have seen profit revisions that are 102% higher than those of companies facing disruption. This trend is accompanied by a significant increase in their EBIT margin expansion rates, surpassing the MSCI World Index.
Conversely, companies labeled as ‘disrupted by AI’ are experiencing downgrades and pressure on their profit margins. This shift indicates a transition from the initial hype surrounding AI to a focus on measurable return on investment and profitability. Morgan Stanley highlights that while AI-driven revenue growth is concentrated in sectors like data center infrastructure, around 89% of AI adopters anticipate gains primarily through improved operational efficiencies.
In light of the recent market volatility, major financial institutions are re-evaluating their strategies to capitalize on discrepancies in valuations. Deutsche Bank has identified an excessive discounting of AI-related risks within the software sector, which has seen stock prices decline by over 20% this year, along with a 21% contraction in valuation multiples. Using its GenAI Resilience Scorecard, the bank has flagged several promising buy opportunities including CLBT, CRM, INTU, and NOW.
Goldman Sachs has introduced a pair trading strategy within the software industry, recommending long positions on firms that are structurally insulated from AI disruption while shorting those whose operations may be more susceptible. Since 2023, sales among companies deemed ‘long’ have doubled, while those categorized as ‘short’ have stagnated. Goldman Sachs anticipates this trend will persist as companies that effectively leverage AI capabilities begin to recover from the recent sell-off.
The evolving landscape underscores a broader realization: AI is reshaping industries not by displacing existing technologies, but by enhancing them. As companies adapt and integrate AI, the potential for recovery and growth in the software sector remains significant, presenting a complex yet promising trajectory for investors.
See also
Bank of America Warns of Wage Concerns Amid AI Spending Surge
OpenAI Restructures Amid Record Losses, Eyes 2030 Vision
Global Spending on AI Data Centers Surpasses Oil Investments in 2025
Rigetti CEO Signals Caution with $11 Million Stock Sale Amid Quantum Surge
Investors Must Adapt to New Multipolar World Dynamics
