As advancements in technology continue to reshape society, debates surrounding the implications of these changes are intensifying. The emergence of cutting-edge tools, particularly in the realm of Artificial Intelligence (AI), has sparked varied reactions among experts and creatives. While some enthusiastically embrace the potential of AI, others harbor concerns about its impact on creativity and originality.
The discussions were particularly prominent at the recent Lagos Book and Art Festival, where the impact of AI on the literary world was a hot topic. Writer, filmmaker, and storyteller Matthew Simpa addressed the fears surrounding AI, characterizing them as “a valid fear that echoes through the literary communities.” He argued that AI should not be viewed as the death of creativity, but rather as its rebirth, stating, “AI does not create meaning; it helps us express meaning.” Simpa emphasized that while AI lacks the capacity for emotional experiences, it can assist human creativity by enhancing expression.
Simpa’s acceptance of AI as a creative partner reflects a growing trend among writers. He noted that he writes more effectively with the aid of AI, describing it as the “craftsman’s amplifier.” In contrast, Carl Death, a Senior Lecturer at the University of Manchester, remains skeptical about the tool, having chosen not to utilize AI in his work despite authoring and editing multiple books. Death expressed a critical yet balanced perspective on AI, recognizing its transformative potential while cautioning against its limitations and biases. “We need to think and reflect quite carefully on what some of the limitations and biases and implications for that might be,” he stated.
Death likened AI to other revolutionary technologies, such as the Internet and the printing press, which also faced moral panics during their introduction. He highlighted that concerns about AI echo historical anxieties about new technologies, such as fears that the printing press would disrupt societal norms. He urged caution against outright rejection of transformative technologies, advocating for a thoughtful integration into educational practices. At the University of Manchester, Death emphasizes the importance of teaching students the legitimate and illegitimate uses of AI tools, reinforcing that these tools should not substitute for deep engagement with literature.
Esther Dumbiri, founder of Legacy Bridge Publishing, described the current era as a defining moment in the intersection of technology and creativity. She asserted that AI poses both challenges and opportunities for the publishing industry, underscoring the need for discernment in what is published. “AI changes everything… we can’t just accept publishing everything and anything anymore,” she stated, noting the disparity between AI-generated works and those informed by lived human experiences.
Dumbiri expressed concern that AI-generated content often lacks the depth and authenticity derived from human experiences. However, she also argued that AI can enhance creativity by bringing human ideas to life. This duality reflects ongoing apprehensions in the industry about maintaining originality in a landscape increasingly dominated by AI-generated content.
Writer and software developer Dele Sikuade further examined the nature of AI, asserting that current iterations are not truly intelligent but rather advanced machine learning systems. He posited that the ultimate goal is to achieve Artificial General Intelligence (AGI), which would surpass human capability. “The AI of today is made from the machine that is either on or off, which is not how the human brain works,” he said, warning that AI cannot produce genuinely original work without human input.
Sikuade acknowledged AI as a powerful tool for generating knowledge while cautioning against overreliance on it. “It can produce knowledge…but if you don’t give it the tight constraints of a very clever prompt, it’ll reach too much knowledge,” he stated, indicating the potential for contradictory outputs. He emphasized that while AI can streamline processes, it requires careful handling to avoid misleading results.
The growing dialogue surrounding AI highlights the need for a balanced approach to its integration into creative fields. As the literary landscape evolves, experts advocate for a marriage of technology and human creativity that preserves the essence of storytelling while embracing the efficiencies that AI can offer. Moving forward, the focus will remain on how to harness AI’s capabilities without compromising the authenticity that defines the human experience.
See also
Meta Acquires Manus AI for $2.5B to Enhance Enterprise AI Tools and Advertising
AI and Platform Engineering Merge in 2026: Key Strategies for Developer Productivity
S&P 500 Gains 0.62% as Chip Makers and AI Firms Drive Market Surge
Fiber Connectivity Surpasses 8 Gbps, Essential for AI and Remote Work by 2026
AI Text Detection Tools Struggle with Accuracy, Leaving Institutions in Dilemma
